Melanoma surgery is usually done in two steps. The first is an excision biopsy, where the spot is cut out with a small margin so the pathologist can confirm the diagnosis and measure its depth. The second is a wider operation called a wide local excision, which takes a bit more normal skin from around the scar. Some people will also talk with their surgeon about a sentinel lymph node biopsy.
Hearing that a spot was melanoma can be a shock. You’re often given a lot of information in one appointment, and not all of it sticks. Below, we go through the usual next steps in order, so you have a clearer idea of what to ask and what might come next.
What happens right after a melanoma is diagnosed?
Most melanomas are diagnosed with an excision biopsy. The doctor removes the whole spot with a small rim of normal skin, about 2mm where possible, and sends it to a pathologist. Removing the entire spot, rather than a sample, gives the most accurate diagnosis.
The pathology report tells your doctor what type of melanoma it is, how thick it is and whether it has features that raise the risk of spread. That report is the plan for everything that follows. The wider, definitive surgery is designed around it, so the second operation is usually booked once the results are in.
What is Breslow thickness, and why does it guide surgery?
Breslow thickness is the depth of the melanoma, measured in millimetres from the surface of the skin to its deepest point. It’s one of the most important numbers in your pathology report.
In general, the thicker the melanoma, the higher the risk that it could come back or spread. Breslow thickness helps guide two decisions: how wide the definitive margin should be, and whether a sentinel lymph node biopsy should be discussed with you. The report may also mention ulceration (a break in the skin over the melanoma) and mitotic rate (how quickly the cells are dividing), which can influence those decisions too.
How wide is the excision for melanoma?
Australian clinical guidelines, published in the Medical Journal of Australia in 2018, set out recommended margins for wide local excision based on Breslow thickness:
| Melanoma type or Breslow thickness | Recommended margin |
|---|---|
| Melanoma in situ (top layer of skin only) | 5 to 10mm |
| Invasive, up to 1.0mm thick | 1cm |
| Invasive, 1.01 to 2.00mm thick | 1 to 2cm |
| Invasive, 2.01 to 4.00mm thick | 1 to 2cm |
| Invasive, more than 4.0mm thick | 2cm |
The margin is measured from the edge of the melanoma, or from the biopsy scar if the spot has already been removed. Within a range such as 1 to 2cm, the exact width depends on where the melanoma is and what the pathology shows. On the face, hands or feet, for example, the plan has to balance clearance with keeping function.
After the wide local excision, the removed tissue goes back to the pathologist to confirm the margins are clear. If they aren’t, more surgery may be needed.
What is a sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB)?
Melanoma that spreads usually travels first to the nearest lymph nodes. The sentinel node is the first node (or small group of nodes) that the skin around your melanoma drains into. A sentinel lymph node biopsy finds that node and removes it so a pathologist can check it for melanoma cells.
Before surgery, a small amount of radioactive tracer is injected near the melanoma site, and a scan (lymphoscintigraphy) maps where it drains. During the operation, a blue dye is often injected as well. Nodes that pick up the tracer or the dye are removed through a small, separate incision.
It helps to be clear about what this test can and can’t tell you. A sentinel lymph node biopsy is used for staging. It doesn’t treat the melanoma. Instead, the result gives your team a better picture of your risk, and it can help them work out whether more scans or medicines like immunotherapy are worth considering. A clear (negative) result is a good sign, but it can’t completely rule out spread.
Who is offered a sentinel lymph node biopsy?
Australian guidelines say a sentinel lymph node biopsy should be discussed with people whose melanoma is 1mm thick or more, or 0.8mm or more with other high-risk features. Many thin melanomas don’t need one.
Timing matters. The mapping scan needs to happen before the wide local excision, because the wider surgery, and especially a skin flap, can change how lymph fluid drains from the area. Once that happens, the true sentinel node may be harder to find. That’s why the node biopsy, if you choose to have it, is usually done in the same operation as the wide excision.
Like any procedure, a sentinel node biopsy has risks. These can include infection, a collection of fluid under the wound (seroma), numbness near the scar, an allergic reaction to the blue dye and, less commonly, lasting swelling of the limb (lymphoedema). Your team will talk through the likely benefits and risks for your situation so you can make an informed decision.
How is the wound closed after melanoma removal?
Once the wider excision is done, the wound needs to be closed. The main options are:
- Direct closure: the edges are stitched together in a line. This is the most common option and suits many wounds on the body, arms and legs.
- Skin graft: a thin layer of skin is taken from another area, such as the thigh, and placed over the wound.
- Local flap: nearby skin and fat, with its own blood supply, is moved across to cover the wound. Flaps are often used on the face and other areas where there is little spare skin.
The choice depends on the size of the wound, where it is, how much loose skin there is nearby and your general health. Because a flap moves skin around, the surgeon will plan around any sentinel node biopsy and sometimes wait for clear margins before using one. You can read more about reconstruction after skin cancer and melanoma removal or about skin cancer surgery in Brisbane.
Wide local excision is often done as a day procedure, but it still carries risks. These include:
- bleeding, bruising or swelling
- wound infection
- a scar that is red, raised, stretched or tight
- wound breakdown, or partial loss of a graft or flap
- numbness or altered feeling around the scar
- a reaction to the anaesthetic
- margins that are not clear, which may mean more surgery
- melanoma coming back at the site or elsewhere
Surgery is the main treatment for early melanoma, and for many people it is the only treatment needed. Results vary between patients, so your surgeon should explain the benefits and risks that apply to you before you decide.
What do recovery and follow-up look like?
Most people recover from a wide local excision within a week or two, although it depends on the size and site of the surgery. Your team will tell you how to care for the wound and when you can return to work, exercise and lifting. A skin graft donor site can look red and raw for a few weeks before it settles.
Scars keep changing for many months. They often start pink and firm, then gradually soften and fade. Protecting the scar from the sun helps, and if a scar remains tight or prominent, there are options to discuss later, such as scar revision.
Follow-up is just as important as the surgery. At each visit, your doctor checks the treated area and your lymph nodes and examines the rest of your skin. How often you’re seen depends on the stage of your melanoma. Having had one melanoma means a higher risk of developing another, so regular skin checks, self-checks at home and good sun protection matter for the long term.
Who is involved in melanoma care?
You won’t be dealing with this alone, and no single doctor works in isolation. Depending on your melanoma, your care team may include:
- your GP, who often makes the first diagnosis and coordinates referrals and follow-up
- a dermatologist, for skin checks, dermoscopy and long-term surveillance
- a pathologist, who analyses the biopsy and excision specimens
- a specialist plastic surgeon or surgical oncologist, for wide local excision, sentinel node biopsy and reconstruction
- a medical oncologist, if further treatment such as immunotherapy is considered
In Brisbane and across South East Queensland, more complex cases are often discussed at a multidisciplinary team meeting, where specialists review the pathology and scans together and agree on a plan. If you’re unsure about any step, it’s always fine to ask your team to explain it again.
Frequently asked questions
What margin is removed around a melanoma?
It depends on Breslow thickness. Australian guidelines recommend 5 to 10mm for melanoma in situ, 1cm for invasive melanoma up to 1mm thick, 1 to 2cm for melanoma over 1mm and up to 4mm, and 2cm for melanoma over 4mm. The margin is measured from the melanoma or biopsy scar and confirmed from your pathology.
Do all melanomas need a sentinel lymph node biopsy?
No. Australian guidelines say a sentinel lymph node biopsy should be discussed for melanomas 1mm thick or more, or 0.8mm or more with other high-risk features. Many thin melanomas do not need one. The decision is made with you, weighing the likely benefits and risks, and before the wide local excision.
Is a sentinel lymph node biopsy a treatment for melanoma?
No. It’s a staging test. The pathologist checks whether any melanoma cells have reached the first lymph node that drains the area, and your team uses that result to estimate risk and plan next steps. Taking out the sentinel node isn’t meant to cure the melanoma, and a negative result can’t fully rule out spread.
Why must a node biopsy be discussed before wide excision?
A wide local excision, and especially a skin flap, can change how lymph fluid drains from the area. That can make it harder to find the true sentinel node afterwards. Guidelines say the mapping scan should be done before the wider excision, so both procedures are usually planned and done together.
Can melanoma be removed under local anaesthetic?
Often, yes. Many wide local excisions are done as a day procedure under local anaesthetic, sometimes with light sedation. A larger excision, a skin flap or graft, or a sentinel lymph node biopsy usually needs a general anaesthetic. Your surgeon and anaesthetist will talk you through the options and their risks.
How often will I need checks after melanoma surgery?
It depends on the stage of your melanoma, so your treatment team will set a schedule for you. Visits are usually more frequent in the first few years. Having had one melanoma raises your risk of another one, so ongoing skin checks matter.
About Dr Justin Perron, Specialist Plastic Surgeon in Brisbane
Dr Justin Perron (MBBS, FRACS Plastics) is a Specialist Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeon. He completed his Australian Fellowship in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (RACS). His training took him from South East Queensland to Perth in Western Australia, and he has worked throughout Queensland, from Townsville to Brisbane, Redcliffe, Caboolture and the Gold Coast.
For melanoma, Dr Perron performs wide local excision and the reconstruction that follows, from direct closure to skin grafts and local flaps. He plans the excision, the closure and any sentinel node biopsy discussion as one process, and works alongside your GP, dermatologist, pathologist and, where needed, oncology team.
Dr Perron presents at surgical conferences, has published articles in a number of journals and keeps up to date with developments across plastic and reconstructive surgery.
He operates at The Wesley Hospital, St Andrew’s War Memorial Hospital, Brisbane Private Hospital and Spring Hill Specialist Day Hospital. His private rooms are at Herstellen Clinic, 490 Boundary Street, Spring Hill, Brisbane QLD 4000. AHPRA registration: MED0000959827.
A referral from your GP or treating specialist is required for a consultation. You can read more about Dr Perron’s background and professional memberships here:
- About Dr Perron
- Australasian Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons (ASAPS) profile
- ANZ Board of Cosmetic Plastic Surgery profile
- Plastic Surgery Hub profile
Disclaimer: This article is general information only. It isn’t a substitute for advice about your own situation. Any surgery, including melanoma surgery and sentinel lymph node biopsy, carries risks, and results differ from person to person. Talk with your GP and a qualified specialist before you make any decision about treatment.
Further reading
- Melanoma skin cancer surgery: the basics
- Reconstruction after skin cancer and melanoma removal
- Is skin cancer surgery serious?
- Scar revision in Brisbane
Medical references
- Medical Journal of Australia. Updated evidence-based clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis and management of melanoma: definitive excision margins for primary cutaneous melanoma (Sladden et al.), 2018. https://www.mja.com.au/journal/2018/208/3/updated-evidence-based-clinical-practice-guidelines-diagnosis-and-management
- Cancer Council NSW. Tests for melanoma. https://www.cancercouncil.com.au/melanoma/diagnosis/tests/
- Cancer Council NSW. Surgery for melanoma. https://www.cancercouncil.com.au/melanoma/treatment/surgery/
- Cancer Council NSW. Life after melanoma. https://www.cancercouncil.com.au/melanoma/after-cancer-treatment/
- Cancer Council NSW. Your health care team (melanoma). https://www.cancercouncil.com.au/melanoma/diagnosis/your-health-care-team/
- healthdirect Australia. Skin cancer and melanoma. https://www.healthdirect.gov.au/skin-cancer-and-melanomas
- DermNet. Sentinel lymph node biopsy. https://dermnetnz.org/topics/sentinel-lymph-node-biopsy
- DermNet. Skin flaps. https://dermnetnz.org/topics/skin-flaps
- DermNet. Skin grafting. https://dermnetnz.org/topics/skin-grafting
